[gosh, mr. mattis. that's *twice* you've quoted me now. thanks! i'm beginning to feel like the BF poster gal
]
i've spent all day (home sick) working on this, and figured it was time to just post the dang thing and stop worrying about how long it was. "women & knives" is a passionate topic in our house! here's what i've learned from talking with nonknife galfriends/sisters...
there are two different issues here: knife design and knife marketing.
>>>> Marketing
yes, it's tough to get women to use knives at all! we're used to fingernails, teeth, dull scissors...marketing means, in part, showing women there's a better way, without becoming Rambette. it's not a quick fix: what's needed is a long-term process of education. knife use is really about self-confidence: being sure enough of yourself and your hands to know no one will get hurt, and knowing you are up to whatever the task is. my galfriends often don't trust themselves with a really sharp knife. one challenge of marketing is how to get the "point" of confident tool usage across to women.
what approach to take depends on how much advertising $$ makers can spend. you could put ads in places women will see them--craft mags would be a GREAT audience to begin with. women who sew, do beadwork, garden, are already accustomed to using/buying special tools. or how about getting a knifegal to write an article for those mags on knife use for/by women--with photos and brand names
or put ads/articles featuring women on the web where women will see them.
another ploy: role modelling--actresses using knives-as-tools on TV/movies. why don't we see jodie foster, the women of "Law & Order" or "Friends" using knives? someone ought to figure out how to get this to happen...if sandra bullock can use a knife safely, maybe my sister will realize she can too.
aw heck, go all out: sponsor a girl scout badge in safe knife use
>>>> Design
we're all saying the same things: current knife designs, for the most part, uh, aren't cutting it for women. (ouch, sorry)
ERGONOMICS: get a bunch of women together, pile a bunch o' sharp things in front of them, and stand back. my SO and I have done this experiment with our galfriends; here's what they (and i) have trouble with:
1. the opening radius is too wide, particularly on most Spydies. i don't know if it's hand geometry, strength or what, but my galfriends have trouble with that thumb-swing motion, because the required arc is too large. if's it's not easy to open, who wants to use it?
2. the mechanism is too stiff. what is a one-hander for big guys is a two-hander for most women. more force against the stiffness is required, and with less-strong hands, the extra force makes gals nervous about slippage (and carnage). opening/closing a stiff knife just "feels" more scary. plus, in an emergency situation, fumbling is a Bad Idea.
3. the locks are problematic. liner locks/lockbacks both require more force to release than most women are comfortable with. ridges on some liner locks (ex: afck) can be hard on women's skin. the placement of the liner lock makes my sisters who spend $$/time on manicures afraid of ruining their investment. my galfriends think lockbacks are dangerous because they have to have their fingers under the blade to push the lock open.
4. the handles are uncomfortable or unsafe to grip. the molding is wrong for our differently shaped hands. corners bite, finger cutouts are in wrong places, handles are too long/too thick to grip well.
5. weight/carry difficulties: many knives are too heavy for already overloaded purses, or for women's pockets (made of lighter materials). many women's clothes lack pockets/waistbands; we need to come up with carry options other than clips. it's too much trouble to dig around in The Purse From H*ll
FYI, the answer is not always the "mini" version, which i feel often lacks some essential quality of the full sized knife. the mini afck's shape is not as graceful/curved as the big afck; the mini axis (oops, sorry, not a spydie) has a narrow pointy blade that is not as solid as the fullsized blade. i want someone to shrink the big one, not take away things i like just to make it smaller.
STYLE/FUNCTION: if it looks tactical, my sisters won't want it. what they do want: handle colors (not pink, please). anodized metal (my galfriends love this!). handle designs a la mr. reeve (cheaper than gems or fancy scale materials). get wild--what about a spydie-type hole (closer to the pivot!) in the shape of a heart? or inexpensive goodies inlaid in the handle, like amethyst, turquoise, etc? or even a small amount of filework, like Corduroy & Frank R's lovely designs. or wood handles. or designs on the blade itself. but no serrations, too scary.
my galfriends like my BM 850 (gentle linerlock, anodized) and my CF cricket (pretty, small, interesting). they envy the purple on my mini socom, but think the overall knife is too scary; the lock is easy but it munches manicures. the black leopard cub i bought from mr. mattis is the one that prompts comments about gang membership
ok, i'm done now. guess you can tell i was just waiting to be asked
my humble abject grovellings for being so wordy. figured the details and ideas might warrant the length. thanks so much for asking, Sal.
silverwing