I read this thread aloud to my babies. My family is deeply grateful for all your words. They express the compassion that makes people human. And although there is some anger and frustration, there is also HOPE.
Just know, the "axe man" did face the LAW. We learned the the USFS can issue tickets and summons through the mail. All they need is a statement from the camp custodian and any evidence like a picture, and WHAMMO Federal charges. Minimum $200 fine with possible jail time. And since these folks were from (AHEM) different state, if they want a trial, will have to come back for legal action.
I felt like so conflicted about how to handle the situation.
My kids KNOW about this place, and my history with it. Now, these trees and this place is fixed in their history. And the trees are theirs, and still mine. And now they belong to each of you good people, who read this,
"heart song".
For a man and father, see the hurt in his children's eyes when, " just a tree" is killed, gave me such pride. I never tell my babies what to think. My wife and I agreed to give them as much information as possible, and then let them make up their own minds. In this case, while they reflected and chose their own way, I did what I do. I acted in the best way I knew that would not endanger them, but still was appropriate. I alerted the custodian, and let him do his job. He did. And afterwards, we had along family discussion about the outcome. That did not change the fact I felt bad for ruining this guy's trip. If I felt comfortable just going and talking to him, I would have done it. But nowadays people react badly when they have their transgressions pointed out to them. I constantly tell my kids do NOT DO WHAT DAD DOES. I am a grumpy old bastard who is just too stupid to know when to keep my mouth shut. Someday it will Prolly get me killed.
Finally, I am personally very proud that this thread has become more than expected. You guys made it about the "wilderness " where you live, where you walk in a forest of people, and where you survive the very real dangers of daily life. And your replies reflect compassionate active minds, and caring hearts. Bully for you!
Finally, please know, I did not mean "NEVER CHOP ANY TREE, NO MATTER WHAT." My true belief is that our "plant tribes" must be shepherded over as any flock might be. Each of us has a space that we watch over, whethe that means a yard or a park or a potted plant. And sometimes pruning or "culling" is necessary.
When I take up rifle in the Fall, it is to thin a herd that has over populater it's range. I am not enough of a "forester"to make those decisions for an entire forest. So I avoid killing a creature which has struggled for life for 10 or 20 or 30 years.
Enough preaching.
Thank you all.
Same Old Shane