Any chance humble old 'rail tracks' A2 could see a testing too? I'd love to see if it made it past the VG10 category.
Also what about 1095? I think it's a good starting point because it's so common.
Only Crucible makes S30V, so all S30V is the same steel. 154CM and CPM154 however are two different steels entirely, same with D2 and CPM-D2.I noticed you have the S30V in 2 categories due to RC hardness. I guess (as I'm pretty new to all this and my brain hurts from all the learning I've been doing) I have a question: Is there a big difference between CPM 154CM and 154CM, or between say CPM S30V and S30V? obviously there are other things that come into play when looking at building a knife for hard use/bushcrafting. But if you could pick one or the other, what might be the deciding factor(s) I'm curious to hear what all of you think on this one!
Ok, so does one or the other have an "edge" on the toughness side of things? I guess that was my original question, is the crucible 154CM tougher than the S30Vou mentioned crucible D2? Again, thanks for any input!
That's quite interesting. S30V does seem to be tougher than 154CM, though CPM154 seems about the same. What's surprising is that S30V seems to outperform D2 in almost all categories. I always had it in my head that D2 was supposed to be tougher having less chromium and being classified as a "tool steel".S30V would be tougher than both CPM154 and D2. The difference between S30V and CPM154 would be so slight I doubt you could really pick up on it in use but the general consensus is that S30 would have the edge here. D2 is not known for being the toughest steel on the block which is why you normally see it mostly in small slicers. There are some that have used it in bigger chopper models but in my opinion there are better choices for this application than D2.
STR
S30V would be tougher than both CPM154 and D2. The difference between S30V and CPM154 would be so slight I doubt you could really pick up on it in use but the general consensus is that S30 would have the edge here. D2 is not known for being the toughest steel on the block which is why you normally see it mostly in small slicers. There are some that have used it in bigger chopper models but in my opinion there are better choices for this application than D2.
STR
So, if the difference is negligible, = S30V having a slight "scientific" edge, Is the CMP154 a lot easier to work with through fabrication ? I'm still learning and don't want to bight off more than I can chew, so to speek
Can't add Phil's 10V knife or his M390 and ELMAX, they wouldn't be on the same planet as the production blades.
What about the elmax in the new zero tolerance 0551?
I used to not be a huge fan of S30V, but I have come to find that Strider's S30V is very nice... I like it a lot.
Did you just admit to not having pre-ordered the ZT 0551?If someone wanted to donate one for me to cut with and get Rc tested.
From my data doing the math percentages ELMAX should be around ZDP-189 performance depending on hardness.
Did you just admit to not having pre-ordered the ZT 0551?
Don't take this the wrong way, but I am disappointed in you:thumbdn:.
I don't know about "donate", but I wouldn't mind letting you "borrow" my Manix 2 in CTS-XHP and my ZT 0551 for your edge retention testing.
i would be surprised if ctp outperformed elmax. however paper velocities do'nt always transmit to expected levels when they are ran on the track. a very respected maker has mentioned to myself that his work with a alloy which has been around for a while & which did'nt raise any eyebrows in the metal circles is showing unexpected developments in his prelim testing.
dennis
That's quite interesting. S30V does seem to be tougher than 154CM, though CPM154 seems about the same. What's surprising is that S30V seems to outperform D2 in almost all categories. I always had it in my head that D2 was supposed to be tougher having less chromium and being classified as a "tool steel".
Now I wonder if all that hype about Dozier heat treated D2 rivaling modern steels was just hype. There also seems to be more complaints about sharpening D2 compared to sharpening S30V.
I'm just curious as to how good CTS-XHP would be as a stainless version of D2 if stain resistance isn't exactly the biggest issue with D2.
Point is D2 is overall less problematic than S30V and although some love S30V the fact is you'll find more issue related stories about that steel than you will D2 so in this regard D2 could easily be seen as the better choice.
STR