Review of the Leatherman Juice S2

Joined
Sep 28, 2000
Messages
347
I had been impatiently waiting for the arrival of the Leatherman Juice since I heard about it from Doug Ritter’s report from the January 2001 Shot Show (www.equipped.com) so when I finally saw them for sale at my local knife shop, the only decision I had to make was which model? I decided on the Juice S2 since it had all of the tools that I normally use and was lighter and thinner than the other models.

The S2 is 3.25 inches long, 1.125 inches wide and 0.5 inches thick. For me, it is a good compromise between size and utility. The side with the blade is slightly thinner than the other side. The tool weighed about 4 oz (120 g) on my postal scales.

image002.jpg


image004.jpg


The knife was quite sharp out of the box, but a few minutes using a Spyderco sharpmaker made it hair-popping sharp. It could cut a hair held on one side with a sharp slicing motion. The knife was used to trim wood, cut cardboard, peel fruit etc and kept its edge very well. The knife, together with the scissors and can opener are accessible without opening the pliers, a very convenient feature.

The scissors are serrated and seemed to be of good quality. The didn’t need to be sharpened and can cut paper just by pushing (i.e. without closing the scissors up).

image006.jpg


The can opener was initially a disappointment. I could not use it to open a can since it had no edge on it whatsoever. To correct this, I used the fine hone of a DMT diafold sharpener to put an edge on the right hand side of the can opener. This only took about 5 minutes. After that, it could open cans without any problems.

image008.jpg


Opening up the tool, you get the needlenose pliers. They are of typical Leatherman quality and although downsized, are very strong. There are also wire-cutters and hard-wirecutters (use the notch) on the pliers.

image010.jpg


Opening up the knife further, there is a lanyard and Philips head on one side, and a set of three flatblade screwdrivers on the other. The small flatblade is a little too big for my eyeglasses, but that can easily be remedied using a diamond hone.

image012.jpg


I also like to have an awl, tweezers, saw, eyeglass screwdriver (the little one in the corkscrew) and hook/knife sharpener with me on fishing trips. I am planning to take the S2, DMT diafold and Victorinox Rucksak for this purpose. The Rucksak weights 3.5 oz so together with the S2 weighs about the same as a Leatherman wave. The advantages of having the 2 tools are that you can use the S2 pliers to hold something while you use some other tool on the Rucksak.

In summary, I am very happy with the S2. It is small, reasonably light weight and has all the useful features that I need. It has become my constant companion.
 
Phwl, thank you for the great review! :)

S2 is on my "to buy" list, so it was nice to hear comments about it beforehand.

I think it isn't yet widely in stock, but well, at least Knifecenter has them now.
It's a good start.

Tuhkis
 
Nice review, although I have to disagree on the scissors. As I posted in an earlier thread, I think they're poor. I compared them to a similar-sized pair of scissors on a Wenger SAK and, to my mind, the Wenger wins hands down for ease, smoothness and accuracy of cutting.
 
The scissors cut everything but paper well. I have the blue and love it.
 
Would you guys do me a favor? Try the SAK's scissors and the Juice's scissors on moleskin? I tend to find that my smaller scissors simply slip off the moleskin instead of cutting it, which sucks because the main reason I want scissors on my outdoor tool is for cutting moleskin and blister foam.

When I first saw the Juice I dismissed it right away, because it seemed a step backwards from the Pulse, which has locking tools. However, the Juice has some really nice features that are making me give it a second look: some tools open from the exterior, the offset screwdrivers are not as good as looking but still work well, and the tool choices are excellent for an outdoors tool. Outdoors, I like the pliers because I can move hot things around with them, though in most cases I could accomplish the same thing with a stick. They can also occasionally be useful in fixing higher-tech camping equipment. This is important because in the ongoing decision about SAK versus multitool, the pliers are the main differentiator for the multitool, and the price is a significant increase in weight. But I may pick up a Juice for the outback.
 
As a lefty NONE of the knife/pockettool scissors work for me. That is why I buy SAK's without scissors and keep two pair of 'snip 'n save' folding scissors on the keychain.

A small needlenose plier is better as well.

Still I DO use the SAK Fireman and Hunter a LOT.
 
Thanks for the very nice review, Phwl. I'm a sucker for multi-tools and that one looks very easy to carry.
 
I carry a Wave on my keychain. My knife dealer showed me the Juice line and I dismissed it right away as gimmicky without a second glance. Looks like I was wrong again. The main selling point of the Wave, for me, was being able to get at some of the tools without opening the pliers.
The Juice looks more keychain friendly AND has the features I want. WAY COOL!:cool:
Thanks for the great review!:D
 
phwl,thanks for the great review. I ordered one for the same reasons that you did. Not only that but you told me how to modify it to make it better.(no thought invovled on my part)Thanks
 
Thank you all for your nice comments. Toolin - what is the problem with cutting paper? As mentioned in the review, I can just set mine up and it glides through normal cartridge paper. It tears up newspaper a bit if I try to push it through but cuts newspaper fine. Could it be that your scissors need sharpening? My scissors have a little bit of wobble but came quite sharp.

Joe - I tried the scissors on hard plastic (the stuff on those spiral plastic book binders), thin leather, fingernails, soft plastic, paper, a mousepad etc and had no problems cutting as long as the material was not too thick. I'd say that they were equivalent to a SAK or PST-II. Not sure the serrated front bit helps though.

I guess the nice thing about the Juice is that you don't have to make the SAK/Multitool choice. You can just take both without any weight penalty (also adds redundancy). There is little overlap between a Rucksak and S2 and with that combination you get everything in a Wave and Supertool (and a longer saw, blade, corkscrew ...) except the file (I like it for sharpening hooks). However, from other people's comments, it seems that the file on the Leatherman is not up to knife sharpening anyway and if that is a big deal, one could go to the Juice model with saw and file anyway (approx 1 oz heavier).

The can opener on the SAK is much better than the one on the Juice even after sharpening.

Misque - I'm impressed that you can use a Wave as a keychain tool! For me, a Juice would be a lot more comfortable.
 
phwl,
I carried a 6" aircraft Aluminium Kuboton for just shy of fifteen years on my keychain.:eek: Making the transition to the Wave wasn't a big stretch. Your right though. The Juice is much better suited for that purpose being more compact and lighter. My car's ignition switch is gonna thank me.:)
I'm really sold on having a Leatherman tool in that capacity. It has come in very handy more than a few times.

I'll be buying a Juice because of the info provided in your review. Again, THANKS!:D
 
The scissors on mine seem to cut very uneven, very sloppy. I have only seen this on paper though and cannot speak for skin, cloth, rubber, ect.
 
...has anyone had a chance to try the saw included with the larger juices?

I'd be interested in a comparison of how the Juice saw compares to:
1) Leatherman Wave saw
2) Regular Victorinox SAK saw
3) Lockback Victorinox SAK saw
4) Wenger SAK saw

It seems like a shame that the Juice can opener is not as good as the Victorinox SAK can opener.

Also on the juice models that have an awl, the awl is supposedly dull---seems a shame.

I've owned a lockback victorinox knife before, and really liked it. I like the idea of carrying, say, both a rucksack and a juice. Problem is I'd also probably want to carry a highend knife -- like if I bought a Sebenza some day :) -- but those three tools combined could get awfully heavy on the trail.
 
Joe:

As requested, comparison on Juice S2 and Wenger SAK scissors on various materials (with the superior performer noted).

Paper - SAK

Thin card - SAK again (but less noticeably superior)

Cardboard - tie

Dr. Scholl's blister padding (my equivalent of moleskin) - tie (both lousy)

And, most crucially, mustache - SAK

Hope this helps
 
Thanks much! So, still no good solution for moleskin. I'm beginning to think that the little folding scissors I have -- slip 'n' snip or whatever it's called -- is going to have to be packed along, and perhaps I'll deemphasize this for my multitool
 
I just picked up a Juice S2 today from a local store. Nice little package. You can access the bottle opener/can opener, scissors and blade with it closed. It fits comfortable in the pocket. The pliers are good as always with the leatherman tools and the wire cutters work well. The scissors on mine cut paper and string well (all I've tried so far). My first impression is that this is a real winner. I haven't carried my full size leatherman in a few years due to it's size, but I miss it often at work. This should make a nice compact alternative.
 
I had a Glacier but it is becoming a gift. Not a bad tool if you aren't as picky as your average knifeknutt, but I still had some problems with it.

I had trouble with the scissors too -- they wanted to tear more than cut.

The rounded outside (with the tool closed) edges of the handles kept pinching my hands when using the pliers, and using the pliers was difficult anyway because of the small handles.

The can opener never wanted to close without being guided into its slot.

Mostly minor problems. but some are too irksome. Going to try carrying a Supertool on my belt again and if I decide that is too big a hassle, I will either buy another Pulse or upgrade to a Cybertool 34 or 41 from my 29.
 
Can we try to figure out the cause of the problem with your scissors? Mine seem fine. I think that the ones that don't work well might be fixable by either sharpening or tightening. Sharpening is easy (easier than sharpening a knife). I normally use the triangle white rod of the sharpmaker about 10 times along the edge of the scissors and then flatten out the burr on the flat side. If it is the pivot, I think a tap with a hammer might do it.
 
I have the S2, the Glacier and the Thunder. (I know but I've been waiting for them for a while and saved my money.) IMHO none of the scissors are as good as the scissors on either the Victorinox or Wenger SAK. (Of these two I like the Victorinox scissors better.) I've used the Juice scissors on cardboard, paper, moleskin and plastic straps on boxes and I find that they tend to be more difficult cut with than the SAKs.

I agree about the can opener too but then I like the old P-38 can openers better than anything else portable.

The awls are all dull but I did manage to sharpen them with my Sharpmaker.

Overall, I'd have to say that I really like the tools. For most of the things that I do daily they are perfect and I like not having to hang them off my belt.

One final thing. I don't particularly like the knife blade, it's the wrong sharp for me and didn't hold up really well when I had to open a lot of boxes. My SAKs tend to hold up better. What do y'all think about the knife?
 
Re scissors -- they cut paper very well, but just chewed cardboard. Seem both sharp and properly aligned. Not sure where the problem is ??? Probably with me, as my wife would say. :p
 
Back
Top