- Joined
- Aug 31, 2004
- Messages
- 143
thanks for the info on what a bob is
Well, it is a good question I suppose. And asked rhetoricaly, I think, since it is rather open ended. Many of the responses bring up valid points. However, as with the statement that only five hundred people in North America can start a fire with a fire bow, the statistic quoted of beyond the capability of 99% of Americans is plain wrong, in my opinion. Did you know that 98.6875% of statistics are made up on the spot? Perhaps that might be true among your own circle of friends and coworkers, but it is not generally true across the nation.
You know, I see many, many posts on equipment here. Bobs, Psks, Fsks, and the latest gizmos. "Stuff" is great, but in most cases the things are in reality just toys for playing survival. Those who have read my posts know my mantra. Anything you own can be lost, stolen, broken, or used up. If survival is dependent upon stuff, in the real world you might well be screwed.
Likewise, the idea that someone is going to rescue you can leave you screwed. That flies in the face of the concept of personal responsibility, another favorite of mine. Don't get me wrong, it is nice when you can dial your cell phone, or set off your emergency locator beacon. I liked the idea of calling in artey "HE and willy pete - fire for effect" or Puff, or medevac. great when you've gotten yourself in a bad jam. but the survival mindset is more along the lines of "I got myself into this, now I have to get myself out".
Now directly to the literal question "how long do you think you would survive in deep woods". Indefinately I suppose. Maybe beyond the average for most people, maybe not. Having a "bob" would be nice. Heck, having more than clothes and shoes would be a plus. But I can make whatever I want or need. As to food, as others have said, I would have two weeks or more to identify and establish my food resources. If it walks, swims, flys or crawls, I can devise some means to reduce it to my posession and make it food. Like a rat in a nest, I'd constantly improve my shelter. And make my own servicable "stuff", improving my ability to hunt, trap, fish, cook, etc., as well as my comfort.
Training? Yes. Above and beyond stuff. Books? Great. If you read a lot and understand what you are reading, that is a great way to gain knowledge others have gained through experience and/or training. Practice? Definately. Put theory into action. Learn all the means of making fire from nothing. Then if you wind up in a needful situation with your six way fire kit, well and good. If not, you know what to do and how to do it. The same applies to the other foundation stones of survival, water and shelter, and food. I have opinions differing from all of the major survival gurus, but none of them stray far from these basic priorities of survival.
Buy or make it..."it" can be gone in a heartbeat. Learn it, and it is with you for life, and especially when you need it. Good posts one and all.:thumbup:
Codger
This I can believe, Skunkwerx. There are no "primitive skills tests" for a person to become a Scoutmaster. Nor is the ability to even make a camp fire with a bic or a match common knowledge among the majority of people nowdays. Heck, I am even reading about scouts being forbidden to carry fixed blade "outing" knives, and in some cases folders. How whack is that? I am curious as to how many scouting merit badges are there now, and how many have been dropped as non-essential or non-pc since the middle of last century. Have they turned from the original focus of scouting? That used to be not only service and citizenship, but self-reliance in the great outdoors.
Codger
PS- My repeating the "500" was not meant to insult you. It was more meant to point out the misconception that wilderness skills are near vanished and near impossible to acquire. Sorry if you were offended friend. It is never my intention to offend anyone here.
Edit: Ohhh! Interesting!!
http://www.usscouts.org/mb/framesindex.html
Make up a personal survival kit and be able to explain how each item in it is useful
Show that you can start fires using three methods other than matches
Explain why it usually is not wise to eat edible wild plants or wildlife in a wilderness survival situation.
Like a fella I used to go hunting with, only knew how to use a GPS, didnt know a thing about plotting a course on a map with a compass, or even simply using and walking with a compass. Something likes this I think is unacceptable. When we start losing the knowledge to simple things like using a compass,.. were just digging our self deeper.
I would like to clear up something, I have used the "Only 500 people in north America can make friction fire" because it is a pervasive statistic.
Actually it's not even a statistic, it's an estimate.
Shorty story: My son's swim & dive team came to our house for pizza and sodas. One of the fathers came to pick up their daughter, and he was dressed in his Scoutmaster uniform. Nice guy. So, I just had to ask him about friction fire.
Asked if he had ever made fire-by-friction, to which he replied "no".
I asked if he had seen it done, in person.
"No" again, he had not. Mind you this is a guy who had made Eagle Scout as a young man , and is now a Scout Master.
In any case, it involves more cognitive ability than flicking a bic, so why do we call it primitive?
I know this is OT, but Scouting in this area includes massive fall leaf-raking projects for the older folks and lots of unit "Good Turns." (Our Troop does four large service projects a year.) However, understand that Scouting is now a "controvsial" program due to the religious and gay issues. It has been driven out of most schools by legal actions and many urban media refuse to acknowledge its existence. Funny, since it was also "controversial" in the minds of some when I was a kid 'cause it was "too left" and now it's "too conservative" for some.Wow! I feel like such an elite now. ONE of FIVE HUNDRED baby!
As far as the scoutmaster goes I am amazed. I was in scouting in the eighties and I fondly remember by scoutmaster as a real woodsman. Always left me with the impression that he only lived in a house to humor the rest of the world. I also remember all of the work projects he had us doing around there area. Right now I can't remember the last time I've seen a group of scouts on any sort of work project around town.
Since it has been 40 years since I had to do this I would imagine that I would last about a day and a half. I readily admit to ignorance, that's why I am here.