Update: I went to the BHQ store today in Utah!
I ended up staying there for 2 hours while looking over the 25+ knives I wrote down and more. Hinderers, WE knives, Olamic, and more. Surprisingly, a lot of the other visitors came in with item #s ready as well, though I don't think anyone stayed nearly as long =)
They were incredibly nice and understanding, especially given that I could touch all their expensive knives for hours without spending a cent there. The people behind the counter (I spent most of my time with a gentleman named Kyle) were obvious knife enthusiasts - their love of knives wasn't something that could be learned through employee training. I almost felt like I belonged in a knife addiction anonymous group with these folks.
Feeling the knives made a HUGE difference. For example, I never knew:
- Olamic knives are AWESOME! Incredible action and F&F is impeccable. Absolutely gorgeous in person, pics absolutely do not compare
- Every single WE knife had exceptional action. Each one I handled was better than the best ZTs I've ever used (562, 560, 920, 452, 450, and more)
- Spyderco Military is HUGE. The BHQ M4 exclusive jade was gorgeous and still so tempting though
- Hinderer knives are beastly yet somehow the Half Track is so tiny. Action is pretty mediocre
- Kershaw Skyline is horrible!
I left with a Boker Mini Kwaiken (BHQ exclusive in CF and blackwash), a BHQ t-shirt, and, some goodies they kindly threw in for free.
Based on this experience, BladeHQ will be the first site I turn to when looking at a new knife.
Like many of you mentioned, it was well worth the visit and one of the many highlights of visiting SLC. Thank you for your recommendations and tips!