• The rules for The Exchange can be found here. Please read and follow them. Stop using Paypal Friends & Family and follow our best practices to prevent getting ripped off or having a bad deal.

Anyone had a knife handpicked by the retailer before ordering?

the925life

Basic Member
Feedback: 5 / 0 / 0
Joined
Mar 2, 2012
Messages
36
I'm looking for a Benchmade 940 with the thinnest blade geometry behind the edge, tight plunge radius at the heel, and a free swinging action with no side to side slop. These are things I would look for if I were picking one out at a brick and mortar, and i don't feel are unreasonable asks considering the price point.

Which online retailers are willing to hunt through their inventory to find a knife that meets a customers spec?
 
Scott W. at usamadeblade, a bf.com supporting dealer, will make sure you're satisfied with your purchase from him. I have first hand experience with him under such circumstances, on more than one purchasing experience.
 
Yes--send an email explaining what you are looking for; they'll likely help you out.
 
From my understanding(other threads), some will and some won't. You will just have to ask.
 
I do this EVERY single time I order a knife. Got sick of getting uneven bevels / grinds / blades off center / blade play / etc.

Every dealer I've ordered from has had no issues checking the knife for me. I've even turned down purchases when the dealer honestly states they see the flaw i am trying to avoid.

I do this now even for knives I am gifting.
 
I actually called Knives Ship Free last year before I purchased a Sebenza and he (it wasn't Derrick) wouldn't open up a couple to find the right knife. Maybe it depends on who you talk to.
 
Scott W. at usamadeblade, a bf.com supporting dealer, will make sure you're satisfied with your purchase from him. I have first hand experience with him under such circumstances, on more than one purchasing experience.

Whitty is an All Star for sure.
 
I've made similar requests at KniveShipFree and they've been very accommodating.
 
Some of those parameters should be pretty constant within the model. "Free-swinging" is all very nice, but I really don't care. Most Spydercos that I buy...are pretty tight at first until they are broken in, and THEN become free-swinging. It's also obvious that some dealer might just loosen your pivot 1/8" and then send it to you.
I do want good centering of the blade and a tight lockup...that's about it.
 
I buy most of my Spydercos from National Knives because they are willing to check inventory for what I am looking for. They even sent my pics of the actual knife from different angles. This was more than I asked for I might add. Keep in mind that this particular transaction was for a $60 knife! I like to reward that kind of service.
 
I've had the following retailers inspect knives prior to shipment:
- GPKnives
- KnifeCenter
- BladeHQ
- USA Made Blade
- DLT Trading

I remember emailing MonkeyEdge to check an SNG for centering and blade play, and got a canned response:

"The short answer (that you won’t like is), maybe.

The long answer: We generally don’t go through all our Strider knives looking for specific aesthetic qualities (blade centering is aesthetic if the knife was tuned to be as strong as it possible, and the result was a off-center blade, as centering the blade after being tuned would equal putting the whole geometry out of balance. But more on that in a bit), as this adds a ton of work to keep things organized (sometimes certain SKUs have 10, 15, 20, or more in stock). Strider knives are purpose built, hard use knives, and are built very much function over form (not to say they don’t make nice looking knives, but their focus is NOT on making them look perfect). Strider does not make marvels of precision machining, but hard use ready for work knives you can bet your life on. Most people say things to us like “yeah, but for $500 I should get the quality of a (enter knife brand)”. This usually comes from a set of expectations that are not totally accurate for the product they are getting.

Think of it like a Humvee and an Escalade. Both are SUVs, both can cost $100,000 and yet they are very different. Humvee’s come factory direct with a crappy paint job, uncomfortable seats, and a lousy ride. If you take it for a ride on the freeway, you will have a pretty rough ride that will not be comfortable. By the same measures, you wouldn't take an Escalade to a warzone. See, each was designed for a specific purpose, and each was built with that purpose in mind. No need to hand finish and make a Humvee beautiful, and no need to give an Escalade smaller steel rims with big knobby tires and armor plating.

We understand wanting to get specifics on knives you are looking at, but in the end it is a Strider knife. The striped finish on the blade will scratch and wear over time (it sort of is supposed too), and the blades aren’t always centered (Mick has a whole rant on how they actually aren’t supposed to be centered due to the design of the knife). The lockup is supposed to be what some people call “sticky” from the shop. Its oversized, so when the lockup breaks in (literally material being ground down, smoothed out and hardened) they match up super secure. The aim to that the knife will lockup super strong and not ever give out in a moment of hard use and abuse. Sure, we have seen perfect Striders straight from the shop, where everything is beautiful, and centered and… But trying to find one that hits all the marks of being perfect is not really a feasible expectation.

Another analogy (we like analogies) is Snap On tools. Some of the best tools on the market, and also at a premium. When those tools are designed and built, they are done so with the assumption that the tools are going to be used, abused, beaten up and generally misused. The tools are designed to withstand that and keep going. Less thought is put into how well that two-tone finish is going to last, or if the handles will stain from oil or grease (they do).

Now we are definitely not trying to sound like jerks, but just explain WHY we don't go through all our knives looking for aesthetic variations. If we just answered 'no' we definitely would have come across badly. When the buyer is wanting more precision and focus on aesthetics than the people who build the knife in the first place, that is a situation set up to fail or disappoint. It has become almost a fashion of late for folks searching for pretty Strider knives (something that just sounds wrong, like wanting a pretty power drill or chainsaw). While they do look BADASS, they look so in a rough, been there-done that, ready for anything way. Strider knives have a sort of "look" that people love and want to get, but sometimes they don't actually know the deal about Striders, and just see a cool knife that they assume is the same as another knife brand.

Tons of people do not agree with this, and that is totally fine! Your money and your knives, and we want to make sure everyone gets what they want. So we tell this to folks because they think they know what a knife is or what they are all about, when in actuality the expectation of the knife does not meet the reality of what it is. We have sold more Strider knives than anyone on the planet, and we are the first to say that Striders are not for everyone. If what you are looking for are hard use tools, designed for that purpose, built to that standard in mind, and ready for whatever you can throw at them, than you want a Strider. If specific aesthetic properties is a determining factor, than a Strider may not be the right knife. Before you think we are trying to be rude, let us explain: I personally have knives that I have purchased for looks alone. I have knives that I liked, but have searched around for the 'right' one. I also have several Strider knives, some with off centered blades, some that had scratches on them fresh from Strider. They still cut, smash, and everything else I expect and trust they will do. That is what they were designed and required to do, nothing more, and they excel at it. So it's 100% okay to want a knife to look a certain way. If your criteria has some level of form outweighing the function of the knife that is a determining factor of whether you want the knife or not, that is awesome, and you may be better suited looking at other makers.

Please let us know if you have any questions, and we will be happy to answer as best as we can."
 
I recently purchased a Nirvana from Knifecenter and under the notes section at checkout I politely write "if possible please check for lock stick, I would really appreciate it Thank You" and sure enough, zero lock stick on the Nirvana I received. I think as long as you ask nicely and not demand anything most retailers would be more than happy to help you get exactly what you are looking for.
 
I'm not sure where I land on the issue.
I do want the knife to be how I like...however, I'm buying a new knife because it is new.
I don't want a knife that has been pawed over and opened a bunch of time while checking to see if some one else wanted it.

Plus, if it's the last knife in stock from a place that checks them for people, that means I have to buy the knife that everyone else decided wasn't good enough for them!
And was probably pawed over the most times too.
 
This topic shows up once in a while and I have had a related question that seems difficult to find an answer to. I am all for dealers to manually check every knife they sell so that customers get the highest satisfaction.

However, my question is, do dealers return to the manufacturer those knives that they have checked but not up to the specific requirement of a customer, or they simply pass them on to future customers who do not ask them to check? Of course I am talking about minor "issues" like a slightly off centered blade (45/55, e.g.).

If it is the former, great! If the latter, I am not sure (I think stabman's post above kind of touched this point if I am not mistaken).
 
I'm not sure where I land on the issue.
I do want the knife to be how I like...however, I'm buying a new knife because it is new.
I don't want a knife that has been pawed over and opened a bunch of time while checking to see if some one else wanted it.

Plus, if it's the last knife in stock from a place that checks them for people, that means I have to buy the knife that everyone else decided wasn't good enough for them!
And was probably pawed over the most times too.

We'll, I'm not quite so picky as the OP. I just asked them to make sure it was centered and there wasn't any blade play.

If Benchmade would do a better job with their QC I wouldn't have bothered. I've never asked a shop to check a Spyderco before shipping.

I agree that I don't want a "new" flipper that's been flipped a few hundred times already. Like a "new" car that's been on 3 different 24hr test drives.
 
I'm not sure where I land on the issue.
I do want the knife to be how I like...however, I'm buying a new knife because it is new.
I don't want a knife that has been pawed over and opened a bunch of time while checking to see if some one else wanted it.

Plus, if it's the last knife in stock from a place that checks them for people, that means I have to buy the knife that everyone else decided wasn't good enough for them!
And was probably pawed over the most times too.

You know, I've had the exact same thought. There's probably a reason that knife is the very last one in the dealer's inventory.
 
Back
Top