- Joined
- Oct 27, 2017
- Messages
- 330
I have turned my attention to fixed blades and find the 4” x 5” field/camp type knife very attractive. Ideally it would excel at light woodcraft and food prep.
I’m no expert, heck I’m barely a novice, so if this post seems overly simplistic or even stupid, please get me on track. But I’d like to know if anyone has used knives from both Carothers and Fiddleback and can tell me how they compare in:
General attributes of the steels used - A1/O2 vs 3V (or the other steels each offers)
Ergonomics
Fit and finish
Edge retention
Ease of sharpening
Toughness
Slicing/food preparation
Wood working
Other?
I know some of you could right a book on these subjects. Many of you seem to really use their blades, as opposed to collect them (which is also very nice), and I was hoping I could get some of your advice so I can see which one to really hunt for.
BTW, I think I would favor convex and high scandi grinds in general for the purposes described. Any practical information would be helpful. Thanks...
And to the Moderators, can I post this in the Fiddleback sub-forum too?
I’m no expert, heck I’m barely a novice, so if this post seems overly simplistic or even stupid, please get me on track. But I’d like to know if anyone has used knives from both Carothers and Fiddleback and can tell me how they compare in:
General attributes of the steels used - A1/O2 vs 3V (or the other steels each offers)
Ergonomics
Fit and finish
Edge retention
Ease of sharpening
Toughness
Slicing/food preparation
Wood working
Other?
I know some of you could right a book on these subjects. Many of you seem to really use their blades, as opposed to collect them (which is also very nice), and I was hoping I could get some of your advice so I can see which one to really hunt for.
BTW, I think I would favor convex and high scandi grinds in general for the purposes described. Any practical information would be helpful. Thanks...
And to the Moderators, can I post this in the Fiddleback sub-forum too?