i would only if it was a functionality flaw, or major amounts of pitting and say a badly rolled or chipped edge. if he is going to simply beat this thing to crap, why bother. its going to lose its polish once he starts taking it to some wood and then if he wants to bring the polish back he has to sand and buff it anyways, which would eliminate the pitting. my kuk is just a user. i dont have it for show and its probably my number one used knife. i know i have removed some of the original steel cleaning it up and removing massive scuffs, but i let it patina naturally, only using rem-oil to protect the blade. not trying to argue or anything, but just saying, IMHO, depending on what your using it for, sending it back would be a waste of time.