The Super CAK and Bonecutter

Discussion in 'Himalayan Imports' started by Yangdu, Nov 7, 2011.

  1. arbiter

    arbiter Gold Member Gold Member

    467
    Jun 4, 2011
    Bill-I don't think there is any danger of HI disregarding continuity of type.This particular knife could well be called a "transitional" model,keeping in mind that Sgt.Khadka's help recently left and Bhakta has taken up that mantle.As was stated above,"a square is not a square if you add sides",however,it does not thereby become formless or nameless and so a name that follows form is indicated.Although with a turnover of Kami's,there is likely to remain some blurring of the lines,so to speak.
     
    Last edited: Nov 10, 2011
  2. shortwinger

    shortwinger Gold Member Gold Member

    Apr 7, 2010
    Arbiter,

    Think of it this way, many different companies routinely bid for contracts on the current BAS model. This model can be considered a specific "type" and comes with specs with size, weight, handle material, blade length, width, etc. No matter what company gets the bid, the BAS is just about as exact as a hand made item could be. I recently ordered about 20 BAS (Service No.1 & Jungle) and while you can get picky and notice subtle differences in feel and balance, they were remarkably similar in size, weight and balance.

    So if this wide range of companies and kami make this model with such uniformity, certainly the cream of the crop kami at HI can be taught to make a correctly spec'ed Bonecutter. And if not, let Sgt. Khadka make however many real Bonecutters as he can and call the others some other name and let them sell on their own merrits. No matter how you slice it, a Bonecutter that looks like a CAK isn't a Bonecutter, just like a Corvette with a Ford engine isn't a Corvette!
     
  3. bric

    bric

    294
    Jun 10, 2011
    Well done Steve! I didn't see that you had done this. I like it even better than the 10/27 one! Maybe it will arrive today. Nice detective work on figuring out the right picture :thumbup:

    Brian
     
  4. Bladite

    Bladite ǝɹnsıǝן ɟo uɐɯǝןʇuǝb Moderator

    Feb 28, 2003
    none taken. based on my design criteria when i begged Auntie to make the bonecutters in the first place... the offering above is not a bonecutter in any way.

    what makes a "bladite bonecutter"? some of the same things that Sgt Khadka has as trademark featuers: hill walnut (no horn, no no no), the flared Chitlangi style butt and nice plate, traditional bolster - none of that japanese habaki stuff ;) minimal to no cho-creep, and more importantly, due to the very high edge bevel and general thiness, the good Sgt's excellent heat treat - he is really good at that. other things: it has to have the high edge bevel - that's a bonecutter trait from the originals. basically no fullers at all. this is not an AK. flat like a GRS would be fine, but the Sgt managed a gentle whole blade curve on the early ones i have - it's lovely. not terribly pointy - more like classic GRS and of course, the original bonecutters.

    it's been 3-4 years now, but maybe i should be more uppity about it ;)

    here's a group shot: top to bottom: VERY large GRS, CAK, the perfect example of a GRS :>, a CAK, and the S-CAK, please to note the differences etc. also how the S-CAK is made to look small ;) those are big khuks - my treasures :>

    [​IMG]


    this is the bonecutter: the most perfect one ever, being the first one made after the S-CAK (that i know of):

    [​IMG]


    behold the glory of those edge bevels!

    [​IMG]

    and three classic bonecutters, with the 2nd and 4th blades being "other" (Bushman/GAK? and a foxy folly):

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    so, imho, the offering above: [​IMG]

    is an excellent looking CAK with 4 pins. not the S-CAK. imho.



    yeah, it would be nice to nail a "type" down in stone as well as the BAS and some models have been. then you can simply order model # xxxx and be assured you get something within a range of variation, even down to a "style" (like Sgt's flared pommels). if i ordered a Humvee and got a H3, i'd be vexed :)
     
  5. GregS

    GregS

    May 6, 2008
    The only resemblance I see to an AK is the fuller and the cho, the blade shape is off, especially the tip. I'm not an expert or anything, but that's not an AK afaic. Although I am certain it will get the job done...
     
  6. Bladite

    Bladite ǝɹnsıǝן ɟo uɐɯǝןʇuǝb Moderator

    Feb 28, 2003
    here's the other advertised S-CAK that i'm aware of: this one is even leafier/fatter, more belly... aiming towards a C-GRS really.
    [​IMG]

    todays: [​IMG]

    but in looking for CAK pix just now? found so many variations that it's boggling.

    main traits to me: the sharp dog-leg bend, the VERY large single fuller. there have been many variations on edge bevels though, from super small to quite big.

    the curve opposite the dog-leg bend shouldn't be as fat there, but that's merely a variant, not a completely different blade. imho.

    some of the newer advertised as CAKs are a little different than old school ones, here, i'll put the pictures side by side if i can:

    [​IMG][​IMG]

    you might have to embiggen your window. to me, the old ones and the new one are nearly identical, barring a longer 4 pin handle.

    the S-CAK as pictured has a very smooth bend, not the pronounced sharp dog-leg.

    in thinning my herd, i had to pick the best of the best, and i kept a lot of the old school, pronounced fuller models, mostly CAKS vs AK, and wood vs bone/horn, and keeping the ones that are closest to what i think the ideal was. many of them had soft looking fullers, or other features (bevels), i felt were too ... variant. off they go. happens.

    i suppose i could flip the picture, and then figure out how to superimpose them, but to my eye, they look VERY close.

    CAK :)
     
  7. moogoogaidan

    moogoogaidan

    666
    Feb 21, 2009
    Over the past couple of years, there's one thing I've definitely learned: the true Super CAK (Wolf's) is a VERY desired khuk. I know some people, including myself, have been tempted to order a custom to the exact specs. But I also know that since it's a one-of-a-kind, getting it just right would be nearly impossible. How likely would it be for Wolf to lend the Super CAK to Auntie so she can send it back to the shop to have the kamis study and replicate it for us eager forumites? I'm sure people like me interested in getting a true Super CAK would gladly contribute to Wolf's/Auntie's shipping costs for this project. What do you guys say? Let's make it happen!! :)
     
  8. Cotherion

    Cotherion

    Aug 7, 2007
    I'm game for one that's like the old version. In wood handle of course.
     
  9. arbiter

    arbiter Gold Member Gold Member

    467
    Jun 4, 2011
    Thank you guys for the time and effort in responding to this question.It looks very much to me like a hybrid CAK/Bonecutter.
     
    Last edited: Nov 14, 2011
  10. Yangdu

    Yangdu [email protected]com Himalayan Imports-Owner Moderator

    Apr 5, 2005
    Thank you all for your suggestions on Super CAK
     
  11. JayGoliath

    JayGoliath

    Mar 27, 2010
    Moogoo,

    Is it this?
    [​IMG]

    Let's hope Sgt gets his groove back ASAP!
     
  12. Bladite

    Bladite ǝɹnsıǝן ɟo uɐɯǝןʇuǝb Moderator

    Feb 28, 2003

    well, yes, it's one of the pictures i'm hosting for the "bonecutter files" :D
     
  13. arbiter

    arbiter Gold Member Gold Member

    467
    Jun 4, 2011
    A fullered,4 pin M-43 if I ever saw one.BTW-The Bhakta made sale post has arrived.It is in every way the equal of my Sgt.Khadka BC.:D
     
  14. JayGoliath

    JayGoliath

    Mar 27, 2010
  15. Jaymo

    Jaymo

    383
    Jan 17, 2009
    Beatiful Khuk. I am quite enamored of my Sgt Khadka BC. One of the reasons I haven't ordered another Khuk is because the BC that Auntie had the good Sgt make for me is as close to the "be all, end all" chopper as I could ask for.
    That, and I'm saving up for a Tarwar and an AK Bowie.
    I believe that, if it chops like an AK or a BC, whoever buys one of those will be very pleased with it.
     
  16. bladeright

    bladeright

    182
    Sep 5, 2011
    now thats what i want, a BC, Tarwar, and AK Bowie. and i will have them. hehe
     
  17. Jaymo

    Jaymo

    383
    Jan 17, 2009
    I also have the HI C-Kerambit and Tamang knife. Both are very good knives, also.
    Though the Kerambit seems to be more of a fighting knife design, the HI 'Bit cuts steak and pork chops like nobody's business. When I received mine, I couldn't resist washing the blade and using it instead of a steak knife. It also has an easy to sharpen false edge.
    The Tamang looks like a Khuk with less bend to the blade. It's not a heavy duty chopper like a BC or AK, but it's a great, rather large, knife for all kinds of uses.
    It chops well, but is not warranted as such. The only chopping I use it for is pruning type work on limbs (twigs?) not much larger than pencil diameter. Green wood only.
    That, and kitchen use such as chopping vegetables.
     
  18. shortwinger

    shortwinger Gold Member Gold Member

    Apr 7, 2010
    DSC03345.JPG
    Here is my Bonecutter, in my opinion one of the best all around kukri ever made!

    DSC03331.JPG
    And here it is with a Large Ganga Ram and a Bura WWII
     
  19. arbiter

    arbiter Gold Member Gold Member

    467
    Jun 4, 2011
    Fine blades Bill.You are very fortunate to have a Bura and that takes nothing from the other two. I have a Sgt.Khadka BC that I am very fond of.That Ganga ram is a monster-just top notch.
     
  20. Ryan M

    Ryan M

    360
    Aug 18, 2001
    I think the main thing to keep in mind is that these new "Super CAKs" are being made under the good Sgt.'s oversight and have his blessing, otherwise he'd never let them leave the shop. Think of them as the "Super CAK version 2.0," maybe.

    I think I sort of see a progression in all the blades pictured. What I kinda envision: Sgt. Khadka wanted to improve on the M-43, so he made the first 2 Super CAKs. Then after refining the design further, he made the Bonecutter. Now, for the Super CAK 2.0, he started with the Bonecutter, added fullers, and most likely made many other changes that are less visually apparent. And then he made absolutely sure that Bhakta made them exactly as they should be.
     

Share This Page