So in the two tests you've run to date, only XCP and Hornady Oneshot are both in the top 5 products for both tests?
Now I'm interested to see if you throw in testing for lubricity, what's the short list of products that score the highest in all 3 tests? I'm guessing Oneshot will be right up there, and if you add the fact it's highly available for US folks, it's gotta be a pretty viable option.
Related item, I've noticed the last couple years in multiple firearm forums, it's been gaining momentum and more people switching to Oneshot. I'm seeing a lot of people (and myself) starting to use the Oneshot as their main general purpose "CLP-like" product. For general CLP tasks on most firearms, and especially for things like hosing down AR BCG's that you need to quickly field clean without disassembly, or spraying into a trigger group that you want to clean/lube/protect without removal. And then supplement the Oneshot with specialized products as needed, such as a bore cleaner product and grease for slides/rails. Just recently switched from using WD40 as my all-purpose knife CLP product to Oneshot, and been pretty satisfied with it. It appears to me the solvent in WD40 (which includes kerosene, among other compounds) is still pretty effective as a cleaner. WD40 works great there's nothing wrong with it at all. But when it comes to multipurpose clean/lube/protect in one product, Oneshot is pretty hard to beat if you want stronger corrosion protection and lube properties, which in fact *is* what I want for folding knives.
