- Joined
- Jun 12, 2009
- Messages
- 125
thanks gents!
? on the steel shank- any impact on comfort? prone to break or rust? I know they spec'd them in the military boot to protect from traps and the like- would you still be at risk w/ nature's stuff w/o steel shanks?
I'd have to disagree w/ the Gortex suggestion though, great in certain environments, but wet jungle not being one of them- they don't breath well and more importantly they will eventually wet through and then they take a long (long) time to dry- you want something that drains and dries quickly, because your boots/feet will get wet- it's inevitable
I agree quality socks are a must, I've been using Darn Tough merino socks for the last 2-3 years after trying dozens of different styles/brands. I don't see myself going to any other sock (they make a wide variety of styles, but all are merino or merino blend).
mtwarden,
Steel shanks are probably totally unnecessary, at least in my opinion, for civilian footwear. The main reason I was told for the presence of the "shank" is for airborne troops, who typically jump out of hovering transport helicopters several feet above the ground with packs and gear. That steel bar acts as a spring and in theory was a cheap way to reduce the number of foot injuries during training and operations (though I'm told ankles still get sprung if you land wrong, intuitively enough). I've taken old boots apart that family members had from their time in the military and the steel shanks aren't all that wide, they can have surface rust if the soles are badly beaten up. I wouldn't want to count on that narrow bit of steel stopping a nail or stake unless it was dead center. The light material of the upper wouldn't stop a puncture either. While I've worn out boots, I've never worried about this.
If you don't plan jump out of a helicopter and aren't counting on your boots to stop that pesky bungee stake from piercing the sole of your foot, the Altima desert boots and their "jungle" cousins are a quite decent boot, wear well and are both light and cool. I had a pair of boots that were for cold weather, heavy as lead gollashes and absolutely horrible for hotter climates. They were very well waterproofed, no water got in or out and my feet took a beating from the rot from just sweating.
For the money, the Altimas win my praise. There are incrementally "better" boots out there, but not for the price you can get a pair of good A. Good suggestion on the socks, I'll look at those as my "alternative" brand. I have been using a store brand merino sock from REI for years that I like a lot. Every pack has at least four pairs rolled up, ready to go. Nothing ruins a hike like blistered feet.
-E