Kitchen KITH 2022

I haven’t had too many chances to use the knife from D Dominick Maone but I did cut some potatoes last night and was impressed. Not only easy cutting but food release was really nice on a “sticky” food like the potatoes. The handle is thinner than I’ve used in the past but is really comfortable for me. I may have to try that thin of a handle sometime. There’s a couple of aesthetic things that don’t affect the function, a couple of scratches and a small area on the choil where one side got rounded over a little unevenly, looks like the hollow grind is farther back on that side and ran off the edge. Really minor things on a really great performing knife. It’s going to take a big role in my kitchen and I’ll pass on any more feedback I have
 
The handle is thinner than I’ve used in the past. I used to make knives thinking the lighter, the better. But lately I have realized that thicker handles are more comfortable and adding some weight is ok. There’s a couple of aesthetic things that don’t affect the function, a couple of scratches and a small area on the choil where one side got rounded over a little unevenly, looks like the hollow grind is farther back on that side and ran off the edge. I’ll keep a closer eye on these two things. I didn’t notice the choil was uneven. I noticed the hollows were not symmetrical. I grind those freehand because I haven’t found a good way to do them with the table.
Thanks for the feedback. I will make sure to check symmetry better. The last few knives I’ve ground also have pronounced distal tapers, which this kith knife does not have. This is something I tried with a 1075 knife that I use almost daily and it really makes the knife perform better. Thanks again.
 
Thanks for the feedback. I will make sure to check symmetry better. The last few knives I’ve ground also have pronounced distal tapers, which this kith knife does not have. This is something I tried with a 1075 knife that I use almost daily and it really makes the knife perform better. Thanks again.
I tried to get some pics of what I was talking about. Hopefully this shows it. I think the first pic shows the hollow grind coming a little further back than on the second side. On the choil shot, you might be able to tell the left side in the picture comes in a little more than the right. I can’t really feel the difference because it’s rounded over nicely, it’s just something I can see in the right light. Overall, a great knife that performs better than any other knife I own

qrZY8bk.jpg


hK8Cs1B.jpg


yZHsmBH.jpg
 
Hey team, sorry I've been stuck in the south island for work. Will get the knife away tomorrow. Will take a little time coming from the bottom of the world.

Just a note, a choil shot or the chefs knives would be very useful when reviewing to get an idea of geometry.

Happy for my knife to be reviewed on here

Unable to PM for some reason...do you have a tracking number? cdhumiston@twc.com
 
Unable to PM for some reason...do you have a tracking number? cdhumiston@twc.com
I hope Nick's knife is quicker to ship than mine. I shipped mine out on 9/23 and the latest update was on 10/7 when it was scanned in Los Angeles!!! They said 10-12 business days to NZ... I guess if Nick gets it tomorrow it's still within the window, but seeing how it took two weeks from South Carolina to California, I have my doubts.
 
Hey man sorry, I do but I'm currently away for work again so don't have access to it, sitting on my desk in the office haha. Last I checked it was showing stateside so shouldn't be far away

It's all good, just thought I'd ask...looking forward to the arrival!
 
The knife I shipped to Nick in NZ was showing "Arrived in LA" on October 7th with no further updates since then. So, today I went to the USPS website to start a search for a missing package and what do you know, there is an update! It just left Honolulu airport this morning! So it took five weeks just to make it a little over half way to the destination. That gives me some hope that Nick might get it before Christmas!

The lady at the post office said 10-12 days...
 
Yes, once it reaches the coast it may wait before moving on with no update. Once it leaves the US, there may be no update until it arrives. I was told by my postmaster that tracking is only between US post offices and only shows arrival and departure.
 
Yes, once it reaches the coast it may wait before moving on with no update. Once it leaves the US, there may be no update until it arrives. I was told by my postmaster that tracking is only between US post offices and only shows arrival and departure.
Yeah, usually once its left the US I can pick it up on local tracking. Pretty unusual to have 4 weeks with no check ins either end though.
 
I have been using Josh's knife pretty much exclusively for the last few weeks. Initially, it was quite difficult for me to use efficiently since I am used to blades with much less belly, so it took me a little while to get used to it. Once I got the hang of it, it has performed really well and I have come to enjoy using it. The thickness behind the edge is just under 0.01" and it looks to be hollow ground on a large wheel. The blade has a uniform distal taper and the knife is perfectly straight and symmetric. I love the thin, no frills handle. It feels really good in the hand no matter how you grip it and does not become slippery when wet. The spine of the knife ahead of the handle and the choil area are slightly rounded, and overall it feels very comfortable.

The food release seems to be a bit better than it is for the slightly convexed FFG blades I am used to for some foods, particularly potatoes and winter squash. For other foods, such as cucumbers, it feels about the same (meaning they stick just as much). Despite the overall heft of the knife, the tip is quite nimble and I have no issues finely dicing garlic or shallots. It also works well enough to trim the fat off some chicken thighs or take the veins out, so I wouldn't be tempted to dirty up an extra knife unless I'd have to process a lot of chicken. The tall blade works pretty well to scoop up food off the cutting board. I think it is really a great all-rounder and I look forward to cooking many meals with it!

9ng2eUk.jpg
 
I wonder if this would be better as a pass around. Everyone keeps each knife for an amount of time and then sends it on. And the last pass is final.
 
I wonder if this would be better as a pass around. Everyone keeps each knife for an amount of time and then sends it on. And the last pass is final.
That's not a bad idea, I would really like to try out all the knives. But I am not sure how practical that is with shipping cost and time? My knife still hasn't arrived at its destination (I think it's close though, last update was from Auckland).

Short of doing a pass around and getting to see and use the knives in person, I think it would be nice to see more pictures and maybe some short reviews of the knives now that people have used them for a bit.
 
I think long term reviews are supposed to go in this thread, if the makers want public reviews. I plan to post a review soon, and I am happy to get a review here too.
 
After a good tiki tour around the pacific Huberts lovely Honesuki turned up on my front doorstep.

Hes happy for a public review so off we go. Well start with form then move on to function. (excuse the streak on the blade just had a quick wipe after boning out a chicken.
WbTsPmT.jpg




Overall the knife is very well finished and very clean. Its an aeb-l blade with what looks like a well executed vertical scotchbrite machine finish. You have to look pretty closely to tell its not a 100% hand satin finish. Handle is cocbolo and blackwood, with a nice satin finish which looks good and is tactile in hand when wet/greasy. The handle fitup is pretty close to bang on and very good for a slim blade in timber bolster. The wa handle is beautifully symetrical and edges rounded where needed. I would not be dissapointed with this handle on a very high end JPN chefs knife, the execution is fantastic.

Huberts (I assume) lazer etched logo is gorgeous and makes me want a lazer. The choil is nicely radius-ed and feels great in hand. Probably my only criticism of the fit and finish is the spine is a bit sharp, a little 45 degree here would add to pinch grip comfort. There is an element of preference here as some prefer a sharp spine on boning knives for scraping bones, Ive personally found this isnt needed.
QQHmQ8y.jpg


On to Function:

A honesuki is really a specialist poultry knife designed primarily to break down birds. Im a bird hunter and butcher most of our own meat from home kill so it will get plenty of use. First impressions after knocking out a chicken is this knife functions fantastically for this role. It is fairly slim stock and a medium grind BTE. The grind is thick enough to the tasks of punching through cartilage and thin bone, but still thin enough to slice well. The edge is a true double bevel as opposed to the asymetrical bevels that are traditional,. I prefer double bevels over assym so this is great for me. AEBL is a great match for this with its fantastic toughness and excellent edge stability properties. The steep cut "k" tip leaves plenty of meat behind the edge which is perfect as the tips of these knives do a bit of levering in thigh and wing joints. Again really my only critcism in funtion is the sharper spine being a little harder on the hand when pushing pressure down through joints etc, this will be a little bit exagerated due to the relatively thin stock compared to a trad honesuki. Nothing 2 mins on the diamond stone wont fix! Over all early impressions are great! I like it much more than my previously owned misono molybdinum honsuki, which are a very well respected honesuki.
MziDcOe.jpg


The knife is light, well balanced and thin enough for general food prep/petty tasks. It will also work well for meat trimming and I pick would deal to small and mid size fish filleting tasks pretty well too. The robust tip means it wont be the best for fine dicing onions or garlic and other precision tip use tasks but that is secondary anyway.
HHS6sWQ.jpg


Overall its a lovely knife, and Im super happy to have it in my quiver. It will get plenty of use for its primary task and will likely end up in my traveling knife roll as well.
Thanks Hubert!
 
Thank you for the review, Nick. I am glad the knife made it to NZ, I was getting a little concerned that the post office might have lost it.

The logo was indeed laser etched on the laser at work. Not sure if it's worth the cost for a hobbyist, even though the price of fiber lasers has come down quite a bit.

I did leave the spine almost square on purpose and only very slightly eased it in front of the handle. After reading your review, I am wondering if that really is the way to go. I mostly use the spine for taking the tendon out of the breast "tenderloin" by scraping against the cutting board, and have occasionally used it for scraping bones clean. But that is a really tiny fraction of what the knife is used for, so it's probably better to make the knife more comfortable for the majority of its uses. I don't normally pinch grip the honesuki when breaking down chicken, but I use it for other tasks and have noticed the sharp spine many times when picking up the knife in a pinch grip. I will try a rounded spine on the next iteration.

Nick, please let me know if you have any trouble with the knife over the long term, particularly with the edge. I made it a bit thinner than the one I use at home and it seemed to hold up in my testing, but I'd like to know how if any issues arise in real use.
 
Back
Top