1. Click here to enter the drawing for your chance to win an Ontario Knives Spec Plus SP8 Machete Survival Knife & Ka-Bar Dozier Folding Hunter, , Bladeforums.com swag or memberships!

    Be sure to read the rules before entering, then help us decide next week's giveaway by hitting the poll in that thread! Entries close at midnight, Saturday Sept 7!

    Once the entries close, we'll live stream the drawing on Sunday, Sept 8 at 5PM Eastern. Tune in to our YouTube channel TheRealBladeForums for a chance to win bonus prizes!

    Questions? Comments? Post in the discussion thread here

Lets talk GEC!

Discussion in 'Traditional Folders and Fixed Blades' started by rockgolfer, Jun 23, 2013.

  1. Shaggy

    Shaggy

    Jan 30, 2012

    Jeff, I love the idea of the coping blade as a secondary option, and as a nice change to the ubiquitous spear blade. However, after owning an original #79 pattern, I don't like it with this particular model. It looks too small for the frame and doesn't keep the clean lines of the original. Having only a coping blade on this one is like putting a 6-cylinder in a Mustang! To be fair, I think the coping blade was perfect for the #92 debut.

    -Greg
     
  2. Double Ott

    Double Ott

    Jan 3, 2011

    This would be a spectacular design to recreate. It would bring back lots of memories with a very functional pocket knife pattern. Like the Remington bullet knife R-4243. Or the Camillus and Ulster Boy Scout patterns.

    My Boy Scout Handbook, copyright 1960.

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]

    [​IMG]



    Tom
     
    Last edited: Jun 23, 2013
  3. kamagong

    kamagong

    Jan 13, 2001
    On a related note, I am curious as to how GEC determines the thickness of blades and springs on their knives. The thickness of the Charlow is spot on. However, the blade on my #73 seems a tad thin given its width. Granted I have very little experience with GEC compared to most here, but a while back someone posted a comparison, complete with measurements, of the #73 to a Remington 1173, its progenitor. The GEC's blade was thinner than those on the original Remington.

    - Christian
     
  4. MarkPinTx

    MarkPinTx

    801
    Aug 21, 2003


    Gotcha. I think there's something cool about the Cub Scout. it's a bit more pocketable than most Scout patterns.
     
  5. jc57

    jc57

    Nov 28, 2012
    Well I can finally contribute to this type of conversation, as I am a newly minted GEC knife owner, just having received my first GEC yesterday, a #68 Pony Jack, clip blade antique yellow jigged bone version.

    All I can say about it is "Wow!" I think that it could become my "one knife." As much as I like my Case knives, I think it'll be GEC for me for any future purchases.
     
  6. richstag

    richstag

    Feb 22, 2007
    Great question too Christian although I do love the thin blade of the 73's :)

     
  7. burnside

    burnside Gold Member Gold Member

    May 30, 2012
    I'm slightly concerned about this as well. I'm sure they will do some re-releases at some point in time, but there are so many good patterns out right now (with more bound to come out), that its hard for me to worry about patterns I have missed out on.

    The patterns I would like to see re-released are...

    #62 Easy Pocket Courthouse Whittler
    #72 Mini Hunter Lockback w/Clip
    #66 Serpentine Jack

    Patterns that I would like to see that have not yet been done by GEC...

    #68 Moose
    #68 "little" Big Jack
    #55 Jack and single blade with more handle options
    #92 w/Single Blade
    #15 with secondary coping blade
    #53/54 Single Blade Jack (I know that there is the Northwoods 54, but I'd like to see a Northfield and Tidioute version as well)
    #65/64 Automatic Stiletto (I don't really care if they do an automatic stiletto or not, but I think it would be neat, so I threw it out there anyways).
    **A Scout or Utility knife would be incredible from GEC!**

    I would also like to see the bottle opener from the 2011 Blade Forums #85 Jack used as a secondary to some other patterns as well (#66, #68, #92, etc..)
     
    Last edited: Jun 24, 2013
  8. jakemex

    jakemex

    Oct 19, 2011
    GEC knives are the "Upper Deck" baseball cards of the 80's for knife collectors. :eek:
     
  9. pmew

    pmew

    Oct 2, 2011
    They have often had a wharncliffe main and a coping secondary; #26 sleeveboard, #61 half congress, #57 geppetto whittler to name a few off the top of my head.....


    As someone who has been desperately searching for the the 2011 BF jack for several months I concur. I found one on a dealers site a while ago and with a WHOOP of excitement added it to my cart only to see a cheeky 'not available sign' in teeny tiny letters at the bottom of the page.

    Paul
     
  10. My first GEC, a Tidioute 73 two blade trapper, was absolutely a bear trap. I put it on the shelf and forgot about it. I could tell it was well made, but it was not what I was after in a using knife. The knife that got me interested in GEC, was a Tidioute 73 shadow pattern 2 blade trapper, that a knife maker had. Maybe he just picked a good one, the pull was tight, but not a steel trap. Over time, I bought and traded for a few blades. One that I really liked, but had to get rid of, was a 5 blade stockman. I couldn't open it sometimes to save my life. Now, I have some Ben Hogans, Toms Choice barlows, 73 trappers, and two 23s. The 23s were sent in to get the tension eased down a bit, but the current knives I have possess not only great F & F, they are not nail breakers.

    Many of the earlier patterns to me are big and bulky, I call them the steroid patterns. Terminator knives. Big, bulky and they might bite you if you're not careful. They did not have that elegance of the old knives that GEC claims to make, or GEC made a pattern that I felt should have a little more flare and curves, and a little less bulk.

    I wish that Great Eastern kept their popular patterns in current production, but I have seen quite a few come up from time to time on the Exchange and other spots. We must be a fickle bunch, or else someone is hoarding them somewhere.

    I really like the path that GEC is going down. If they can make such a great knife as the TC #15 barlow, then they can make the premium stockman (301/8OT size) I'm looking for. I would also like to see a scout/camp knife from them.

    As far as variations go, I have been fine with whatever model I can get my paws on, as long as it's not yellow bone, or plastic (one of the -lons). However, I've got more #15 barlows than I can remember. Ebony, soup bone, antique yellow bone (fickle? ;)), antique bone. Clip and spear.
     
  11. rockgolfer

    rockgolfer Gold Member Gold Member

    Mar 1, 2008
    I had never thought about this before, very interesting. I just looked over my knives and this is pretty constant along the line. I have not had any ill effects myself but I know you have Kevin and I do seem to recall any issues with blade's is usually on the larger models. I would be curious to hear what GEC has to say on the subject.
     
  12. oldrifleman

    oldrifleman Platinum Member Platinum Member

    Jan 5, 2006
    Would love a GEC (440C) scout knofe. I know 1095 is far better, but I have not trained my son yet (he is 6, 2 more years to Cub Scouts). Steven
     
  13. Bob W

    Bob W

    Dec 31, 2000
    Absolutely my feeling as well. That all changed, for me at least, with the introduction of the White Owl. What a graceful and slender knife, perfect, especially with the extra touches (pinched bolsters, etc.).
     
  14. pertinux

    pertinux

    Feb 1, 2012
    [​IMG]

    Wow. I'm glad you like your knife, and like it that much. :)

    I agree with sentiments regarding some of the earlier releases. I've wondered how much is due to an eye toward the collectors' market, and how much is the excitement and challenge of new patterns and variations.

    For me, I'd like to them choose a "basic" jack-- a #15 or #66 or one of the new #68 Pony Jacks, in the 3.5" range with simple appointments-- and produce it as a regularly available item. Maybe three default patterns?

    The goal would be to be able to point new/future costumers toward a knife they can have, a known quantity instead of yet another knife that, by the time it's established and comes into awareness beyond the small bubble of collectors and nuts, is no longer available and won't be.

    ~ P.
     
    Last edited: Jun 24, 2013
  15. rockgolfer

    rockgolfer Gold Member Gold Member

    Mar 1, 2008
    I can see where everyone is coming from with the patterns and availability. If you get past the members of this and other knife forums how do people get to know or buy GEC knives? With less then a handful??? of store fronts around the world its not like most even know about them to buy in the first place. Maybe someone will come across one for sale at a gun show or something they will learn of the brand and consumers like that will buy whatever they see in front of them if they like it. They are not going to say"boy I wish you had a congress today, that two bladed jack would be mine if it was just a clip blade instead of spear". Only folks like us really care about the nuances of knives, to everyone else it is something cool you buy when you break or lose your other(if you have one at all). I just dont see how or why they would want to up production. They dont sell out everything and you can still find one example of most knives made still around. I completely agree with Jakemex as I was 10 when upperdeck hit the shelves and boy let me tell you it changed baseball cards. Everyone started coming out with elite lines trying to match the glossy better quality. It changed the entire industry of cards very quickly. GEC is already doing this to the traditional knife world. I prefer the exclusivity. If I ever come across another carrying one then I know they know what good cutlery is ;). Sure I hate that I can not just buy a courthouse whittler but think of the value. Look at CASE and their business model it is like new cars, the second you buy one it loses a 1/3 of its value. I buy and try new patterns with GEC knives because I can swap/trade or sell for pretty much retail value or heck above in some cases. I really dont want the knives I own to lose value because everyone can buy them but thats just my take on it. :)
     
  16. kamagong

    kamagong

    Jan 13, 2001
    That makes two of us, though I'd pick the #73, #15, and the #62 half-whittler. All GECs are well-made, but these patterns just look right and have that old-time "elegance" that Dan referred to.

    - Christian
     
  17. pertinux

    pertinux

    Feb 1, 2012
    I agree-- those three represent the foundational goodness of "GEC" very well, with a little something for everyone.

    As for other patterns, this may well be redundant with their other offerings, but I'd still love to see a 3.25" "regular jack"-- shorter and rounder than the current #15s, longer than the #25s.

    ~ P.
     
  18. Omega Leather Works

    Omega Leather Works

    Jun 13, 2007
    I know that I found the whole mystique of "GEC" super appealing before I would admit to myself that I even cared about traditionals. I kept seeing GEC this and GEC that. Had no idea what it was. Then one day I started a thread about nice packaging in the general forum and someone said, if you want nice, get a GEC. It drove me nuts! I'm no knife expert, I'd never claim to be, but I'd say I'm fairly well versed on the various available brands out there. Imagine my surprise when I found out that the brand everyone was going on about, a NEW brand mind you, was a company making SLIPJOINTS of all things.

    It didn't take long for my curiosity to collide with my wood carving hobby. Now I get it. I get the whole darn thing and I'm genuinely excited about a whole new genre of knives (for me) to obsess over, and it's hardly limited to GEC.

    I agree with you. I'd like to see them remain the way they are for now. They (GEC) are COOL and that's something every knife company wants (needs?) to be.

    I'm not sure that I'd be here now if it was Case alone (for the most part) that was responsible for ushering in the new fan base. As far as I can tell, GEC is doing just about everything right. ;)
     
  19. pmew

    pmew

    Oct 2, 2011
    Rockgolfer, you mentioned;

    Well I completely agree. I have yet to actually meet anyone who carries one, in fact I have yet to actually meet another person who even knows what GEC is! Exclusivity is nice. I lent my white owl to someone the other day (last wooden wednesday probably) for some reason, and I could see them eyeing it with interest, they didn't ask though. I did not tell them, I just put it happily and mysteriously back into my pocket. (Of course if they had asked I would have babbled on for ages!)

    Paul
     
  20. jc57

    jc57

    Nov 28, 2012
    Interestingly enough, one finds a number of GEC fans on the Case Collectors Club forum. I guess if you are into traditional knives you tend to be into all of them.

    I too would like to see some of the older patterns that I missed be available again. I love the 2012 forum knife, for example, which I believe is a #74 Saddle Trapper pattern.
     

Share This Page