I recently acquired a find from the workplace of my recently deceased stepdad. I believe it actually initially belonged to his father because I vaguely remember seeing in the garage at our house when I was a kid.
Anyway, When I found it down at his shop the handle was pretty rotted and it had obviously been rehung at some point because it was the wrong style handle. It had a single bit handle which didn't make much sense to me. The head pretty much fell off so I just tossed the handle without snapping a pic first.
The head was covered completely in what looked like dried tar? The handle also had a bunch of this "tar" substance all over it and I wondered what in the world it had been used for. Roofing perhaps? I don't know. It is a full sized double bit. To me it looks like a Western / Lippincott. It had no markings on it other than a stamped number "5" on the head which I only discovered after restoration had begun. I'm not sure of what the original make is.
The head as I found it:
After removing most of the tar-like substance with a drill and wire brush bit, it started to reveal what was underneath:
Some more grinding this time with a stripping bit and drill. I was pleasantly surprised that it had no cracks with only minor surface pitting and clean cutting edges:
After more time spent on sanding with various grits of sandpaper and finally a polish, the head really looked beautiful. I didn't want to remove too much of the metal so I left most of the pitting as I think it gives it a classic, old look:
I'm not sure what the number "5" stamped into the head means. It doesn't depict weight as it weighs about 3.5 lbs:
I ended up at my local hardware store to pick up a new (and correct) handle. It was a nice piece of hickory with some good looking grain. I hung it and applied boiled linseed oil and viola! I've got a great tool now:
Boiled linseed oil on the handle and some Rem Oil on the head until I can get around to making a custom leather sheath which is my next project. I'm happy with the final result: