I have often felt, especially after owning a bunch of the high carbide super wear resistant steels, that the debate between them is a little overblown. If a person is halfway decent at sharpening, then any properly heat treated steel will get you through the day, day after day, unless you have some super extravagant need for high volume cutting of hard/abrasive materials over short periods. This is why I love the less expensive fine grained, simple alloy steels like 1084, 15N20, AEB-L - and why my favorite steel of all, LC200N, is just a more expensive fine grained steel. When properly heat treated, they are tough and take and hold good edges. Of course, this applies to 1075 and 8670 also.
Anyway, I'll put more feelers out on Monday about this.