Let's talk about LL Bean axes for a minute. Subtext, I can't believe I'm going down this hole again.
Let's start with me having something new to show off. An LL Bean Hudson Bay made by Snow & Nealley. Classic poll stamp and the old-time Snow & Nealley wedge that looks like a little axe. On the original haft as well! I have to say that this looks and feels like the oldest S&N Hudson Bay I've come across (to be fair, I have limited experience). It's soo...wedgey and stumpy and solid and rudimentary..and over weight!
It got me thinking again about the history of LL Bean and S&N, and the evolution of S&N Hudson Bay axes. Once again I searched for old LL Bean catalogs (and will post some pics here so I don't have to go through that again). I was struck by some things that, well, make my mind (that requires order) explode.
grafton, whom I miss on this forum, seemed to have had the most knowledge at the time about S&N Hudson Bay axes.
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/maine-axes-post-em-up.946603/page-7#post-15614225 Through many comments and post (mostly on this thread) one would get the general sense that S&N Hudson Bay (and LL Bean Hudson Bays made by S&N) had a thicker poll and a less dramatic beard from the 30s to 50s, and went more dramatic in the 60s and beyond (based on the popularity of the Collins HB being new to the market?). Here is a link of an older S&N HB, one I wish I never sold...top 3 axe-related regrets for me
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/maine-axes-post-em-up.946603/post-17408969
So here are a couple of things that mess my mind up with this topic. My new LL Bean is a thick wedge, short and stoat. I included pics of it next to the new +2012 S&N Hudson Bay for comparison. When thinking of an evolution of an axe, you would think this would be next to the first they ever made. Compare that to this (same post as above)
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/maine-axes-post-em-up.946603/post-17408969 everyone would agree (sure, I'll speak for everyone) that this is their 30-50s model. So what's up with the 1936 LL Bean HB?! That's a dramatic beard if I ever saw one. 1945 HB Crusing axe? What's that?
So, see my new axe, it's amazing! And anyone who want's to fill in gaps, fill away!!!!!!!