- Joined
- Mar 17, 2017
- Messages
- 108
You are right. The TRE is a great knife but this was somewhat of a design flaw that it was often criticized for: It was either poor to open with the disc or poor to open with the flipper and too easy to open as a legal two hand knife.
The reason for this is simple in my eyes: A smooth and easy opening thumb disc knife will have a rather weak detent whereas a good flipper or a legal (hard to open) two hand knife will have a strong detent. You cannot have these two things at the same time. A knife is either a good thumb disc opening knife or a good flipper.
Early TREs had a medium strong detent. That way you could use all opening methods but nothing was exactly easy to use. It was relatively hard to open with your thumb, too easy to open with a finger on the blade and didn't provide enough resistance to flip it easily. If you look at the older threads here there were a lot of people that were disappointed because it was too hard to flip. In some German boards you could read that it wouldn't be a legal two hand opening knife because it was too easy to open with one hand even without thumb disc or flipper installed.
IMO this was the major reason for the TRE never taking the place on the market that it really deserved. Lionsteels solution was to offer detent modifications for everyone. I know hand full of people that made use of their offer and had their TRE's detent either weakened so that it became good thumb disc knives or strengthened so that they became good (fool proof) flippers and legal two hand opening knives.
Later TREs were equipped with a stronger detent from the factory. If you want to open one of these with the thumb disc you will have a hard time. IMO a new TRE with thumb disc is one of the hardest opening knives and certainly the hardest opening knife of this size.
I think Lionsteel /Molletta were just consequent this time. It will be a great flipper and a great two hand opening knife.
The reason for this is simple in my eyes: A smooth and easy opening thumb disc knife will have a rather weak detent whereas a good flipper or a legal (hard to open) two hand knife will have a strong detent. You cannot have these two things at the same time. A knife is either a good thumb disc opening knife or a good flipper.
Early TREs had a medium strong detent. That way you could use all opening methods but nothing was exactly easy to use. It was relatively hard to open with your thumb, too easy to open with a finger on the blade and didn't provide enough resistance to flip it easily. If you look at the older threads here there were a lot of people that were disappointed because it was too hard to flip. In some German boards you could read that it wouldn't be a legal two hand opening knife because it was too easy to open with one hand even without thumb disc or flipper installed.
IMO this was the major reason for the TRE never taking the place on the market that it really deserved. Lionsteels solution was to offer detent modifications for everyone. I know hand full of people that made use of their offer and had their TRE's detent either weakened so that it became good thumb disc knives or strengthened so that they became good (fool proof) flippers and legal two hand opening knives.
Later TREs were equipped with a stronger detent from the factory. If you want to open one of these with the thumb disc you will have a hard time. IMO a new TRE with thumb disc is one of the hardest opening knives and certainly the hardest opening knife of this size.
I think Lionsteel /Molletta were just consequent this time. It will be a great flipper and a great two hand opening knife.