1. The rules for The Exchange can be found here. Please read and follow them.


Discussion in 'FEEDBACK: The Good, The Bad, The Ugly!' started by avoidspam, Jun 17, 2016.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. rickmenefee


    Jun 26, 2005
    Tony doesn't deserve the respect Vince! He has done nothing for the slip joint trade. Not to mention every custom slip joint maker that's ever requested pattern's or help. Hell he just wasted 40 years

    He should already be in the hall of fame!!!
  2. VCM3

    VCM3 Dealer / Materials Provider Dealer / Materials Provider

    Oct 26, 2005
    Oh hell I know that. That is why I was so surprised to find out that no conversation had took place before an order of hundreds of those Zulu's were put in. OP you're upset about flippin,how about flippin ideas. Sorry we're hijacking this thread but flipping is a mute point. No one is putting a gun to anyone's head saying you better write a check.

    Now thievery ,using a good man's name for profits,that's something for a thread perhaps.

    Enjoy the entertainment https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9_EX1Vo7ri8
  3. major_works


    Aug 30, 2014
    I recently got the auto text from you saying there was a new SFO up for preorder. I immediately go to your preorder page to grab one. They were all spoken for already. I'm talking seconds after the text came in, 10 seconds max. It's stuff like that that convinces me that the process is gamed. Very frustrating but I'm not a hardcore collector, so I don't know the secret handshake or password or whatever it takes. So it goes.

    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
  4. Jack Black

    Jack Black Gold Member Gold Member

    Dec 2, 2005
    Heck, I didn't SELL it to you! :D ;) :thumbup:

    I'd forgotten how fast threads move outside the Traditional forum! :eek: :D
  5. Jsega51

    Jsega51 Gold Member Gold Member

    Feb 11, 2015
    Major works, sometimes everyone reserving a knife from Mike at CK will be put into standby because he doesn't know how many knives he will get. As soon as the first person enters a reserve, all variants show red and everyone will be placed on the list in order of their reserve time. So even though it appears you missed out, it looked that way for everyone. You might get lucky and get the email when he knows how many knives he has to make available.
  6. Jack Black

    Jack Black Gold Member Gold Member

    Dec 2, 2005
    I like OLD knives, I don’t buy them on the internet, I go to antique shops and flea-markets. I come across lots of knives I like, if the prices are too high I don’t buy them. I’ve given plenty of the knives I buy away, I’ve never re-sold a single one (again laziness is probably a big factor). I’ve also been given lots of knives, both old and new, by posters I’ve, for the most part, never met.

    This thread started off in the Traditional sub-forum, which I think has a very altruistic atmosphere, and non-commercial guidelines. For those who don’t post there, many of the posts here perhaps seem kind of strange.

    I’ve learned a lot over the years since I’ve been posting in the Traditional sub-forum, and that learning hasn’t cost me a penny (my Gold membership is just to support the site, and optional). Like others, I often get contacted by other members who I don’t know, asking me about a particular knife they have. I wish people would just post to the forum, so others get the chance to chime in, and also to share the information, but I don’t mind too much, and always try to help. However, a while back I received a PM from a particular member, unknown to me, asking about a particular Sheffield-made knife. His PM started with “You seem to be something of an expert on ******** knives...” Now that certainly wasn’t the case, but as I later realised, he had simply done a search on those knives, and found that I’d posted a couple of threads about them. By chance, I was able to tell him quite a bit about the knife he was asking about, including who had actually made it, which factory it was made in, and when. The reply I received simply said, “So, how much is it worth?” At that point, I checked his posting history, and discovered that while he had been a member here a couple of years, he had never made a single post, which didn’t involve him selling a knife. Sure enough, within a few days, the knife he had asked me about, also popped up for sale. Perhaps I should have charged him a consultancy fee? ;) But then I’m not out to make a profit from folks here, just not my thing.

    I’ve nothing whatsoever against sales, they’re an important part of our hobby, but I’d rather they didn’t leak into the other forums, as for example when someone puts up a knife for sale, then spams other forums with images of the knife – as in ‘Here’s what I’m carrying today (and it just happens to be on sale, in big letters, in my sig line)’.

    As has been said, fashions come and go. I find the hysteria for particular patterns scary at times, all that ‘I NEED’ stuff...the sort of thing I’d have got a clout round the head for as a child :rolleyes: Another reason I prefer old patterns and old knives ;)
  7. Murindo

    Murindo Gold Member Gold Member

    Jul 4, 2010
    Flipping has been going on as long as the Exchange has been open. Wait six months to a year and the "knife of the moment" will be going dirt cheap. You have to have the patience to wait it out.
  8. supratentorial


    Dec 19, 2006
    I've also gotten similar emails and given long replies then realized that the real reason for contacting me was for a value. All the history was of little interest.

    There were and still are a lot guys flipping old knives. Though the values and interest in old knives has declined a lot recently. The Remington market was very competitive a few years ago. I can't tell you how many beautifully preserved oldies I lost at auction and then saw back on Ebay a week later for double the price after a fluff and buff that removed any remaining finish and diminished the value to me. I remember at least one time that I did end up paying the huge markup because I wanted the knife so badly.

    Anywho... the forum is lucky to have a guy like you.
  9. knifeswapper

    knifeswapper Knife Peddler Dealer / Materials Provider

    Sep 3, 2004
    Since you are insinuating something under the table here and we are in GB&U, I will respond with some facts. I assume we are talking the #14 TC Barlow.

    There are less than 10 of each single blade and less than 5 doubles anticipated; thus that is how many were accounted in my system. Every one I expect to receive was placed in the system. The text was sent at 12:50:59 PM Central. The first reservation was submitted received at 12:52:09. Some were going into "Standby" at 12:52:37. All were in "Standby" by 12:52:56. Nothing was even touched, much less closed in 10 seconds. Once they were at least 250% oversubscribed I closed the reserves to save me money (each confirm email costs).

    So, I hate that you didn't make it there in time. But this only happens in the rare occasion that there are a tiny number of knives expected. I don't know of any better way to do it. But you couldn't be more wrong, at least in my case, about there being some secret process. The reason it gets so hectic a couple times a year is because the system is so fair.

    Jsega51 is correct in that previously I just told the system I was getting one, so that all but the first reserver went into "Standby"; but that was just more confusing to folks that wanted a thumbs up/down so they could look elsewhere. Probably won't do that again and didn't do that on the #14TC.
  10. rickmenefee


    Jun 26, 2005
    Mike Latham is a class act!
  11. mtangent


    Dec 6, 2011
    How would everybody feel if GEC simply raised prices 50%?
    Comes to the same thing as far as buyers are concerned. Flippers wouldn't have any wiggle room.
    One way of looking at this, is that GEC have mispriced their offerings, & selling too cheap. The flippers are simply confirming that in the real world.

    There have been a few comments about GEC prices approaching custom prices. Why shouldn't that happen? There are many comments about GEC being the same quality as custom knives.
  12. Ryouchijtx


    Oct 26, 2011
    -GEC has their own set pricing to dealers and from dealers to customers that they already feel is fair.

    -Having the pricing go up wouldn't change flipping at all. People flip for anywhere from 50-100-200% at times.

    -GEC prices are nowhere near custom prices from dealers. Perhaps on ebay or on the secondary yes. But nowhere near straight from a dealer.

    -You're wrong, GEC's are not near the same quality as higher end custom traditional knives. Case/Bose knives would be a more fair comparison
    GEC's are fantastic as I have many but it's an unfair comparison/a completely different level of fit and finish.
    Last edited: Jun 18, 2016
  13. JB in SC

    JB in SC Gold Member Gold Member

    May 19, 2001
    GEC makes a nice production knife but in no way comes close to any custom I own.
  14. meako

    meako Gold Member Gold Member

    Sep 4, 2006
    well put.
  15. meako

    meako Gold Member Gold Member

    Sep 4, 2006
    That must be frustrating and somewhat disheartening. Mike although I have purchased only once from you (yes I snuck around your OS shipping policy by having it sent to Esnyx who sent it on to me in OZ muuhaahhaaa) I reckon you are an upright dealer and strive to be fair and equitable for your customers.Sadly short runs will result in someone missing out no matter how hard you try. Sad but true.
    Moving forward -and I know this will sound obvious - I believe you would have some serious clout at GEC business level. Could this be used to suggest an extension of short runs that have flown out the door before. like a re run.
    Or would that just increase the frustration -i dunno -just thinking out loud .:foot::)

    In response to a previous post -I don't think we are "whining".
    Expressing an opinion -yes. Expressing a distaste for the practice of "flipping" yes.
    Believe me- as an Englishman who grew up in Australia or "whinging pommy" as we are known I can tell you that complaining about anything in this country
    particularly the weather makes you as popular as a pork chop at a Bar Mitzvah.

    so just to be clear I have decided to make a distinction between trading , selling, swapping, dealing and flipping. All slighty different, all perfectly legal but in the words of Bob off Sesame Street "one of these things is not like the others.":)
    Last edited: Jun 18, 2016
  16. mtangent


    Dec 6, 2011
    It is very similar though. The flipper is essentially an extra middleman in the supply chain. A level between retail & final resting place.
    I can understand the irritation, being an accumulator & user. But I just can't see one middle man being that much worse than another. They both are paying a seller an agreed on price, then finding a buyer at a higher price. The world is big & complicated.

    My understanding is that GEC sells to retailers, like Mike Latham, who then sells to individuals.
    Many supply chains have an extra level, a wholesaler, for example. Perhaps this fourth level provides some value, and market forces are naturally creating that fourth level in the GEC story currently.
  17. Ratbert


    Jan 1, 2016
    Hahaha...I'm thinking that your father and mine would have understood each other quite well.
  18. knifeswapper

    knifeswapper Knife Peddler Dealer / Materials Provider

    Sep 3, 2004
    GEC actually has two levels. Distributors and Dealers. Distributors are required to have a resale license and maintain $36k/yr in volume. There is really only one distributor that I know of that wholesales GEC and that is Blue Ridge Knives.
  19. mtangent


    Dec 6, 2011
    Thank you.
  20. major_works


    Aug 30, 2014
    Mr. Latham, it may be that I simply don't understand your reservation system. When I got to the page as quickly as I did after receiving the text and saw all variants already marked red, I thought that meant that they were all reserved and that I had no shot at purchasing a knife. Thus I didn't even try to reserve one. I thought there was no point. Am I to understand that if I had put in a reservation at that moment, I may still have been afforded an opportunity to buy one? I'm not sure if that's what you meant in your reply.

    I will assert again, however, that I was at the early reservation page within seconds of receiving the text and saw only red. Maybe the text was delayed in getting to me somehow, I don't know. In any case, it was disappointing but I know I wasn't the only one shut out.

    Yes, it was the 14 TC Barlow. I've missed out on any/all 15 TC Barlows since I've been hanging around Traditionals as well. I have a 15 Huck's boy's knife and I just figure its basically the same except for the bolsters. There was no stress involved with purchasing it either, so I guess I'm ahead of the game.

    Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page